2010-12-28 Planning Comm Agenda Packet CITY OF MENDOTA HEIGHTS
DAKOTA COUNTY,MINNESOTA
PLANNING COMMISSION
AGENDA
December 28,2010 - 7:00 P.M.
1. Call to Order
2. Roll Call
3. Approval of the Agenda
4. Approval of the November 23, 2010 Planning Commission Minutes
5. Hearings
a. Case No. 10-34: William Gacki—Critical Area Permit for a 3-season porch. Public
Hearing 7:00 P.M.
6. Verbal Review
7. Adj ourn
Auxiliary aids for persons with disabilities are available upon request at least 120 hours in
advance. If a notice of less than 120 hours is received,the City of Mendota Heights will make
every attempt to provide the aids,however, this may not be possible on short notice. Please
contact City Administration at 651-452-1850 with requests.
Planning Commission Minutes
November 23,2010
CITY OF MENDOTA HEIGHTS
DAKOTA COUNTY,MINNESOTA
PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES
NOVEMBER 23,2010
The regular meeting of the Mendota Heights Planning Commission was held on Tuesday, November 23, 2010, in
the Council Chambers at City Hall, 1101 Victoria Curve at 7:00 P.M.
The following Commissioners were present: Chair Povolny, Commissioners Hennes, McManus,Norton(arrived at
7:02 p.m.) and Viksnins. Those absent: Commissioner Field. Those present were Assistant to the City
Administrator Jake Sedlacek, Public Works Director/City Engineer Mazzitello, and NAC Planner Carie Fuhrman.
Minutes were recorded by Carla Wirth.
Approval of October 26,2010,Minufes
COMMISSIONER MCMANUS MOVED, SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER HENNES, TO APPROVE
THE MINUTES OF OCTOBER 26,2010,AS PRESENTED.
AYES: 4
NAYS: 0
Commissioner Norton arrived at 7:02 p.m.
Hearin,-s
PLANNING CASE#10-33
Western Culinary Institute,Ltd. (Le Cordon Bleu)
1315 Mendota Heights Road
Conditional Use Permit for restaurant dining and caf6 facility
Planner Carie Fuhrman presented the request of the Western Culinary Institute for a conditional use permit(CUP)to
allow the operation of a public restaurant and caf6 facility as part of the existing Le Cordon Bleu culinary school at
1315 Mendota Heights Road. The property is zoned Industrial and restaurants are allowed as conditional uses. The
building permit was approved in 2004 and included a CUP at that time; however, the restaurant never materialized
so they are making application at this time. Ms. Fuhrman displayed a picture of the subject site and identified the
location of the restaurant and cafe in the existing Le Cordon Bleu Culinary building, in the northwest corner of the
backwards L-shaped building. This space is currently being used as storage as it was never finished. The restaurant
and caf6 portion of the facility will encompass 8,200 square feet of the approximately 70,000 square foot building.
It will provide seating for 108 indoor guests and 28 outdoor guests. The two outdoor dining patios are each 10.5 feet
by 20.5 feet in size located on either side of the main entrance surrounded with black wrought iron fence three feet
in height. The fencing will incorporate flower boxes, lighting and a new door to each of the patios is also proposed
along with two new concrete walks from the main entrance doorway to the sidewalk.
Ms. Fuhrman stated the hours of operation for the restaurant are Monday through Friday 11 a.m. to 10 p.m.,
Saturday and Sunday 6 a.m.to 10 p.m. The proposed hours of operation for the caf6 are Monday through Sunday 6
a.m. to 10 p.m. At the time of the 2004 approval, the City approved hours of operation for the restaurant to be
limited to 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. from Tuesday through Sunday. At that time, however, the caf6 portion of the facility
was not part of the project proposal.
Ms. Fuhrman stated the existing parking lot consists of 536 parking spaces and the Code requires 435 parking spaces
so there is adequate parking. They propose landscaping around the outdoor dining patio, which is not required by
the ordinance and appears to be sufficient to act as a screen or buffer. A lighting plan was not submitted but the
applicant proposes exterior illumination integrated into the black wrought iron fencing and four exterior wall
1
Planning Commission Minutes
November 23,2010
sconces at the front of the restaurant and cafe areas, along the west elevation. Signage is planned but a sign plan has
not yet been submitted. The applicant has indicated signage will comply with the ordinance. The existing trash
enclosures will be utilized for the proposed use.
Ms. Fuhnnan explained that because the restaurant and cafd are being proposed as a teaching component for the
culinary trade school staff recommends, if the CUP is approved, that it would terminate in the event the culinary
trade school ceases operation at this site. Following holding the public hearing, the Commission may consider
approval based on findings and conditions as contained in the staff report, or consider denial of the application based
on a finding that the proposed restaurant and cafd do not meet the zoning ordinance requirements and are not
consistent with the intent of the CUP criteria.
Ms.Fuhrnan stated staff believes that the proposed restaurant and cafd uses are consistent with the site, surrounding
area, and the existing use of the property. The existing building, site and parking areas appear to be sufficient to
accommodate the new uses in the building. Staff recommends approval of the requested CUP subject to the five
conditions detailed in the staff report.
Commissioner Hennes asked if concerns were expressed when the original CUP was approved in 2004. Assistant to
the City Administrator Sedlacek stated the hours of operation were a concern at that time.
Commissioner Viksnins asked who the applicant is. Ms. Fuhnnan explained that Jeffrey Brim made application on
behalf of the school.
Commissioner Viksnins asked about the recommended condition tying the restaurant and cafd to the teaching of the
school and if the operation could not be continued if the students came to an agreement with the school to operate
the restaurant and school. Ms. Fuhnnan stated that was a condition of the original approval in 2004 along with the
condition related to reserving parking spaces for the restaurant and cafd.
Chair Povolny asked whether the hours of operation had changed from the original 2004 approval. Ms. Fuhrman
explained that it limited hours to 11 a.m,to 10 p.m. from Tuesday to Sunday for the restaurant, and the cafd was not
part of the original application. The current application is for a seven-day operation.
Howard Roston, representing the applicant, stated he is also a resident of 1728 Trail Road. Mr. Roston stated this
will be another good place to eat and requested that the Planning Commission recommend approval.
Jeff Brim, Career Education Corporation, 2895 Greenspoint Parkway, Hoffman Estates, Illinois, explained they are
the parent company and have five major school entities, Le Cordon Bleu being one of the entities. Mr. Brim
explained that the schools across the country are under the Western Culinary Institute.
Commissioner Viksnins asked if Laura Magnuson is the owner. Mr. Brim explained they rent the building and Ms.
Magnuson is with Northmarq,the owner of the building.
Commissioner McManus asked if staff will be added to operate the restaurant and cafd.
Kevin Sanderson, Le Cordon Bleu School President, stated they have an operation at Brown College that started in
July of 1999. That lease is expiring so they would like to consolidate all operations at the Mendota Heights address.
He advised that some staff will be added but the restaurant and cafd will predominantly be operated by students
under the direction of staff and chefs.
Commissioner McManus asked about their baking program. Mr. Sanderson stated that program is part of this
School and those students will also be utilized at the cafd.
Chair Povolny asked about their current operation. Mr. Sanderson stated it is at Brown College and would be
moved to this location since that lease is expiring and their student population is growing.
2
Planning Commission Minzrtes
November 23,2010
Commissioner Viksnins asked if they are requesting expanded hours to accommodate the existing restaurant that
would be moved to this location. Mr. Sanderson stated originally, when this building was built, the college only
offered Tuesday through Friday but with an expansion to this location and the additional parking availability, they
want to extend hours of operation.
Commissioner Viksnins asked what they expect for customer traffic. Mr. Sanderson stated they believe it will be a
viable operation and cost point opportunity to offer student products at a reasonable price that will draw traffic and
serve that segment of the community.
Commissioner Viksnins noted a recommended condition is that the CUP would be in place as long as the restaurant
and cafe are tied with the school. He asked if they agree with that condition. Mr. Roston stated they have no
preference whether that condition remains or is removed.
Commissioner McManus asked how many students are at the school. Mr. Sandstrom stated they currently have 770
students.
Chair Povolny opened the public hearing.
Seeing no one coming forward wishing to speak, Chair Povolny asked for a motion to close the public hearing.
COMMISSIONER NORTON MOVED, SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER VIKSNINS, TO CLOSE THE
PUBLIC HEARING.
AYES 5
NAYS 0
COMMISSIONER NORTON MOVED, SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER HENNES, TO RECOMMEND
APPROVAL OF THE CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT AS REQUESTED AND SUBJECT TO THE
FOLLOWING CONDITIONS:
1. THE RESTAURANT AND CAFE CUP WOULD TERMINATE IN THE EVENT THAT THE
CULINARY TRADE SCHOOL CEASES OPERATIONS AT THIS SITE;
2. THE HOURS OF OPERATION FOR THE RESTAURANT SHALL BE LIMITED TO: MONDAY
THROUGH FRIDAY 11:00 A.M. TO 10:00 P.M., SATURDAY 6:00 A.M. TO 10:00 P.M., AND
SUNDAY 6:00 A.M. TO 10:00 P.M. THE PROPOSED HOURS OF OPERATION FOR THE CAFE
SHALL BE LIMITED TO MONDAY THROUGH SUNDAY 6:00 A.M.TO 10:00 P.M.;
3. THE SCHOOL SHALL RESERVE ADEQUATE PARKING SPACES FOR THE EXCLUSIVE
USE OF RESTAURANT AND CAFE CUSTOMERS;
4. THE APPLICANT SHALL APPLY FOR AND RECEIVE A SIGN PERMIT PRIOR TO ANY NEW
SIGNAGE BEING PLACED ON THE PROPERTY; AND
5. THE APPLICANT SHALL APPLY FOR AND RECEIVE A BUILDING PERMIT PRIOR TO ANY
CONSTRUCTION WORK.
Commissioner Viksnins asked about Condition 1 that tied the CUP to the school. Mr. Sedlacek stated that is a
carry-over condition from the 2004 approval; if the school is not in operation and the City wanted the restaurant and
cafe to remain in operation,it could amend the CUP.
AYES 5
NAYS 0
Chair Povolny advised the City Council would consider this application at its December 7,2010,meeting.
Discussion of December MeetilZQ
3
Planning Commission Minutes
November 23,2010
Mr. Sedlacek indicated that the Planning Commission has frequently requested to cancel the December 28, 2010,
meeting and, at this time,there are no planning applications.
COMMISSIONER NORTON MOVED, SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER MCMANUS, TO CANCEL
THE DECEMBER 28,2010,PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING.
AYES 5
NAYS 0
Verbal Review
Mr. Sedlacek gave the following verbal review:
PLANNING CASE#10-30 Daniel and Jodi Saltzman Critical Area Permit
• Scope of the project changed and application was withdrawn.
PLANNING CASE#10-31 Richard Nelson Wetlands Pen-nit
• Approved by the City Council as recommended by the Planning Commission.
PLANNING CASE#10-32 Robert and Katherine Thompson Critical Area Permit
• Approved by the City Council as recommended by the Planning Commission.
Mr. Sedlacek stated the Commissioners have been provided with electronic copies of the 2030 Comprehensive Plan
Update that was approved by the Metropolitan Council and implemented by the City Council. He stated if
requested, copies of the Storm Water Management Plan are available for review. Mr. Sedlacek explained that the
Mississippi River Critical Area Plan was not included in the Comprehensive Plan because the DNR is undergoing a
rulemaking process so there will be changes.
Mr. Sedlacek encouraged Commissioners to complete an on-line training course offered by the League of Minnesota
Cities. He explained the City would be eligible to receive a discount if there is a case related to a land use decision
if a quorum of the City Council,Planning Commission,and appropriate staff complete this training.
Chair Povolny adjourned the meeting at 7:24 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Carla Wirth,Recording Secretary
4
,
E,
b NORTHWEST ASSOCIATED CONSULTANTS INC .
4800 Olson Memorial Highway, Suite 202, Golden Valley, MN 55422
Telephone: 763.231.2555 Facsimile: 763.231 .2561 planners@nacplanning.com
MEMORANDUM
TO: Mendota Heights Planning Commission
FROM: Bob Kirmis / Stephen Grittman
DATE: December 22, 2010
MEETING DATE: December 28, 2010
SUBJECT: Critical Area Permit for Three Season Porch Addition
CASE NO: Case No. 10-34; NAC Case 254.04 - 10.36
APPLICANT(S): William Gacki
LOCATION: 1133 Cascade Lane
ZONING: R-1, One Family Residential
GUIDE PLAN: LR, Low Density Residential
Background and Description of Request
The applicant, William Gacki, is seeking a Critical Area Permit to allow the construction
of a three season porch addition to his home located at 1133 Cascade Lane. The porch
addition is proposed to be located in the rear (west) yard of the property and measures
approximately 208 square feet in size (17'-4" by 12'-0").
The subject site is zoned R-1, One Family Residential and is located within the Critical
Area Overlay District of the Mississippi River corridor. Section 12-3-17 of the Zoning
Ordinance stipulates that any work conducted within the Mississippi River Corridor
requires a "Critical Area Permit".
According to the applicant, the proposed three season porch addition will provide an
area where his handicapped son (bound to a wheel chair) will have access to the
outdoors.
Analysis
Comprehensive Plan. The subject parcel is guided for low density residential use by
the City's 1999 Comprehensive Plan. Thus, the request to construct the three season
porch addition request is consistent with this land use category, which provides for
single family development upon the subject property.
Critical Area Permit. As noted, any work conducted within the Mississippi River
corridor requires a Critical Area Permit. The proposed three season porch addition
would replace an existing concrete patio (of similar dimensions) in the same location.
As a result, no increase in impervious surface coverage is proposed, no change in
grade is planned, no soil loss is anticipated during construction, and no slopes are being
affected. As a result, the proposed three season porch addition should not have a
negative impact on the aesthetic integrity and natural environment of the Mississippi
critical area.
Setbacks. As noted, the three season porch is proposed to occupy the current footprint
of a concrete patio. According to the submitted site plan, the porch addition is to be set
back 22'-3/4" from the west property line. Such setback is well within the minimum 10
foot side yard setback imposed in the applicable R-1 and Critical Area Overly Districts.
The Critical Area also requires a minimum 40 foot setback from the edge of any bluff.
There are no bluffs in the area that would be affected by this project.
Vegetation. The replacement of the existing concrete patio with the three season
porch addition will not result in the loss of existing on-site vegetation.
Finish Materials. In view of the submitted building elevations, it appears that the three
season porch addition is to be finished in vertical siding which will match the existing
structure. The submitted elevations do not however, specify proposed finish materials.
As a condition of permit approval, the three season porch should match the existing
structure in materials and color.
Action Requested
After a public hearing, the Planning Commission may consider one of the following
recommendations-
1.
ecommendations:1. Approval of the Critical Area Permit to allow the proposed three season porch
addition, based on the following findings: the project shall not involve
landscaping, paving, changing in grades, soil loss, or altering of slopes;
therefore, it shall not jeopardize the aesthetic integrity and natural
environment of the Mississippi River corridor critical area, subject to the
following condition:
a) The proposed three season porch addition match the existing home in
finish materials and color.
2
OR
2. Denial of the Critical Area Permit to allow the proposed three season porch
addition, based on the finding that the project will negatively impact the
aesthetic integrity and natural environment of the Mississippi River corridor
critical area.
Staff Recommendation
Considering that no landscaping, soil loss, grade or slope alteration is planned, the
proposed three season porch addition should not have a negative impact upon the
aesthetic integrity and natural environment of the Mississippi critical area. As a result,
Planning Staff recommends approval of the Critical Area Permit.
Supplementary Materials
1. Draft Findings for Approval
2. Application materials dated December 7, 2010
3. Site Location map
3
Draft Findings for Approval
Three Season Porch Addition in the Critical Area
1133 Cascade Lane
1. The proposed three season porch addition will have little or no visual impact on
the critical area or surrounding property.
2. The proposed three season porch addition will create no grading or erosion
issues.
3. The proposed three season porch addition will have minimal impact on the land
as it does not involve landscaping, paving, grade changes, soil loss, or altering of
slopes.
4
�r
�0
®gym
ewe —
1133 Cascade Lane
PSG
5
ark
P t r
IvFalls,�L.
c
a
s
J
Site Location Map
0 Water/Wetlands City Roads
Major Roadsp arcels
�
®oaa®� Municipal Boundaries
City Of
kA MAk JAAL
Mendota Heights
APPLICATION FOR CONSIDERATION
OF
PLANNING REQUEST
Case No. `
Date of Application
Fee Paid
15765-
A Iicant Name: (: PH: 6 % a"
pp (Last) (First) (M)
- E-Mail Address:
Address: 1 L57
(Number &.Street) (City) (State). (Zip)
Owner Name:
(Last) (First) (M)
Address: — Zi
(Number& Street) (City) (State) (zip)
Street Location of Property in Question: � �14 SCA ,40
Legal Description& PIN of Property:(Complete Legal from Title or Deed must be provided)
AT o 1rf/�f ff-,O�PEATY `C���1-t ri -
Type.of Request: Variance-
Rezoning
Conditional Subdivision Approval
Use Permit
_Conditional User Permit for P.U.D. Wetlands Permit
Preliminary/Final Plat Approval 3f Critical Area Permit..
Comprehensive Plan Amendment Other(attach explanation)
Applicable City Ordinance Number Section_ _--
Present Zoning of Property Present Use
Proposed Zoning of Property Proposed Use
I hereby declare that all statements made in this request and on the ditional material are true.
I further authorize City Officials and agents to inspect the abs pr erty during dayligf�t hours.
(Signature a Appli ant) 1
Date Received - � ° --
( ignature o Owner) j
1101 Victoria Curve Mendota Heights,MAY 55118 • (651)452-1850 FAX(651)452-8940
www mendota-heights.cOm
December 4, 2010
William&Joan Gacki
1198 Fallsview Court
Mendota Heights, MN
55118
To:
City of Mendota Heights
Issue: Planning Request—Critical Area Permit
1101 Victoria Ctuve
Mendota Heights, MN
55118
Re: Mendota Heights Planning Application
Critical Area Permit
Property:
1133 Cascade Lane
Mendota Heights,MN 55118
Legal Description: Lot 1 in Block 6 of Ivy Falls Addition, Dakota Co, MN
Torrens Certificate Number 137120
Real Property Tax ID 27-37600-010-06
Specific Action: Construction of a 3 Season Porch
Dear City Execrative:
My family and I presently live in Mendota Heights at 1198 Fallsview Court and as of
December 1, 2010 closed on a home which is also in the Ivy Falls neighborhood and the
address of that home is 1133 Cascade Lane. We plan to move into the 1133 Cascade
Lane home within the next two months.
We are changing homes because due to our family's needs we require a home that is
oriented to single floor living as opposed to a multi-floor home.
The purpose of this application is to seek approval to construct a modest three-season
porch in the home at 1133 Cascade Lane.
The prime reason for this construction is to allow our son Daniel to get easy access to
fresh air and sunlight. Our son Daniel is 29 years old and he is significantly handicapped.
He lives with us. He absolutely requires a wheel chair and we seek the porch so that we
can literally wheel him into a room with fresh air, sunlight, etc. The porch shall be on the
same level (first floor) as his bed room. This is by far the easiest way to give him a taste
of the"outdoors".
Our contractor for this work shall be The Transformed Tree at 2239 Carter Avenue, St.
Paul, MN. The Transforined Tree group has done significant work at our present home at
1198 Fallsview Lane.
Transformed Tree has supplied a series of drawings which give you a perspective of the
dimensions of the porch and the appearance of the porch when viewed from the outside.
With regard to these drawings, the only modification may be the addition of skylights to
allow in a little more sunlight.
We appreciate your review of this material and should there be a need for any additional
information, please call us. My home phone number at the 1198 Fallsview Court
address is 651-552-1020. Since we have not yet moved, any written communication
should be sent to:
William&Joan Gacki
1198 Fallsview Court
Mendota Heights,MN
55118
In closing I would like to say that after having lived at the 1198 Fallsview Court address
for almost 20 years, we think so highly of Mendota Heights that we jumped at the
opportunity to stay in the neighborhood with the home on 1133 Cascade Lane. We have
the greatest respect for the appearance of the neighborhood and hopefully our
construction plans reflect that. The new home will not have the view of the woods that
our present home has but our son's needs come first and we do need to live in a single
floor arrangement.
If there is anything we can do to help this process run smoothly and quickly please lets us
know.
Respectfully sub itted,
William L. Gacki
December 16, 2010
City of Mendota Heights
Planning Commission
Linda Shipton
1101 Victoria Curve
Mendota Heights, MN 55118
Re: critical area permit for 3-season porch at 1133 Cascade Lane
Dear Ms. Shipton,
Per your request,the landscaping at this site will not be affected in any way by the
construction of a 3-season porch. The location of the porch is to be over an existing
concrete slab patio which is surrounded by grass and a few small shrubs. No trees will be
removed or affected by this construction.
As for grading, since the concrete slab is level, as is the yard, there will be minimal or no
grading required.
Sincerely,
5!
'�i-
' J
Joan Gacki
Jgacki@comcast.net
651.552.1020
CITY OF MENDOTA HEIGHTS
NOTICE OF HEARING
December 7. 2010
TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN:
NOTICE is hereby given that the Planning Commission of Mendota Heights will
meet at 7:00 P.M., or as soon as possible thereafter, on Tuesday, December 26, 2010
in the City Hall Council Chambers, 1101 Victoria Curve, Mendota Heights, Minnesota, to
consider an application from William and Joan Gacki for a Critical Area Permit for a 3
season porch located at the following described property:
Lot 1 Block 6 Ivy Falls Addition (PIN #27-37600-010-06)
More particularly this property is located at 1133 Cascade Lane
This notice is pursuant to Title 12 (Zoning), Chapter 3 of the Mendota Heights City
Code. Such persons as desire to be heard with reference to this Critical Area Permit
will be heard at this meeting.
Nancy J. Bauer
Acting City Clerk
Auxiliary aids for disabled persons are available upon request at least 120 hours
in advance. If a notice of less than 120 hours is received, the City of Mendota
Heights will make every attempt to provide the aids, however, this may not be
possible on short notice. Please contact City Administrator at 452-1850.
Dakota County, MN
}761
cYQ
ib F
X11- � ,�:�, .�i •- ''''i „•,
36
2.i
C.}
`d c,
i
N. I i z �
64
N_ 71 d,:
i N J 5
G: I
I'i __—--•-� �,T V� tel=
11 ST a
``• 1 5
L
�g fet= Yr
s r 48 a F F. C' fvlAgr c PARK Oft
AQ
Disclaimer., Map and parcel data are believed to be accurate, but accuracy is not Map Scale
guaranteed. This is not a legal document and should not be substituted for a title search, inch = ���feet
appraisal, survey, or for zoning verification.
pnd
palong iirc to
-asv. PeelF Labels
: .a W r osePop- W Edge T11
iplate 510C"' 4 a \
u® iaa1� i
State Of Mn Johnson Paul S&Beverly Oberst Peter J &Laura S
-asurer-Auditor 1149 Cascade Ln 680 Arcadia Dr
Mendota Heights Mn 55118-1802
1: lighway 55 Mendota Heights Mn 55118-1803
Hastings Mn 55033-2343
Foreman Richard T Tste Messerich Jeffrey J
Goodrich Leon R& Katherine 688 Woodbridge Dr 703 Maple Park Ct
1157 Cascade Ln Mendota Heights Mn 55118-1793
Saint Paul Mn 55118-1803 Saint Paul Mn 55118
Johnson Scott W Yackley Roger J &Mary A
Garrett John T 711 Maple Park Ct
691 Woodridge Dr 689 Maple Park Dr
Saint Paul Mn 55118-1809
Mendota Heights Mn 55118-1711 Mendota Heights Mn 55118
Driscoll Edward J Rathke Daniel&Mary
Millikan Leslie A 679 Maple Park Dr
701 Woodridge Dr 704 Woodridge Dr
Mendota Heights Mn 55118
Saint Paul Mn 55118-1810 Mendota Heights Mn 55118-1711
Johnson Glora&Lynn Tste Mcclung John D& Paula E
Fabel Gary R&Mary K 683 Arcadia Dr
709 Woodridge Dr Saint
Arcadia Dr
M,r
Saint Paul Mn 55118-1801 Saint Paul Mn 55118-1801
Iota Heights Mn 55118-1809
Fritz James& Lois Siegel Dianne D
Cammack Richard B&Ann B 714 Woodridge Dr 727 Woodridge Dr
734 Woodridge Dr Mendota Heights Mn 55118-1811
Saint Paul Mn 55118-1811 Saint Paul Mn 55118-1811
Macke Aaron M &Sarah A Perlman Arthur M
Berg David A 731 Woodridge Dr
711 Woodridge Dr 2216 Swan Ct
Saint Paul Mn 55118-1809
Mendota Heights Mn 55120 Saint Paul Mn 55118-1811
Petersen Joanne M Fergen Joseph M
Prather Stephen A 688 Arcadia Dr 700 Woodridge Dr
1133 Cascade Ln Saint Paul Mn 55118
Mendota Heights Mn 55118-1803 Mendota Heights Mn 55118
Freeman Allen &Toba J Hulse Sara L&Todd H
677 Arcadia Dr 754 Woodridge Dr
Saint Paul Mn 55118-1801 Saint Paul Mn 55118-1811
x �s
O� &� 3a d���p� @G�r eplicz� 8a eiachure eJTFi IV, '!S'L 9�.!LdSCSY jo
C 7 iTi,9 a B-�tifi�^���^r-AVER
,.::---- e._ ,..._a......:�. zaaa!�xnEa(J S;4 i:,u1O -f -. Ya'.aaSC•+s Ee-,a.EvNerS Frn••ibn
CL
LL
t'-,! N
' I. d-
z �--
� m;
I
..0 -,0le
I
O-,ZZ Ll -
� ..6
ca
c
Ln
I N v
LU J =
�z
U o
I
I
i
I
0L-,L5
�I
m
in
o
u�
I I i i
I I I I I
I I I I I
I I I I I
i I I i I
------------------
I I i
I I I
I I I
I I I
I I i
I I I
I I
I I n I
I I I
I I I
I I I
I I I
I I I
I I I
I I I
I I I
I I I
I I I
-----------�--------
------ --
I
I � I
I � I
I .b-sl I
0._ CL
i
I i
-------------
----- ------
rrhh I
I
I�
LU
I, I
i
I
I i
VI
M7
I
�I I
I�
I
5..
II j C
It
I)
I
-I
I �_ co
I I
I
I I
i I
i I
I I
I I
I I
I I
I I
I I
.Lit L-,£L I
I
I I
•9.f n
N
h -
u ^O
—
4N„u
hr ��
HN
i
'N''
77 J 4'
Hy
u W
N ui
C)
r �
�M v/
W /
l.
"
sr �?
`n N
4
H `
u � /
n u W
my WJ I
4
N hH �N
L L,
N
LN ��
�!
F —
� 0 a
u —
NN 00
J
!1
i
H O
N
N u
w � w
P
ad
�3=_0��
—�� 4-4
r _ O
Ln
z r �i-
Ga m
i
I
� N
ca
CA)
ca
i u =r
lLl
i
I � �
m
i
m �
L r�
-I
I
i
i
i
i
i
..9L/GL OL-IG
m'
m
o
I i I
I 1 1 I I
I I I I I
I I I I I
I I I I I
----------I--------
1 I I
I I I
I I I
i I I
I I I
I I I
I I I
I I n I
I I I
I I I
I I I
I I I
I I I
1 I I
I I i
I I I
I I I
I I I
1
I \ I
(
W \ 1
I
---- -- \\ ---------.—
i
------------
i
I
I
I v ® .9-,L
LU
l; I
1 .1
(i
.E101
�I I
I I
it _0
li I
l 4 'i-''
12
Co
I
4 0
I �
I I
1 1
I I
I I
I I
I I
I I
I I
Li I IlD
.P,91 I
k_ .Z/L L-,EL
I
I 1
-
I -
^o
H
—
u
(DO
Hu
—
H N y e O
H �•
HCH " O
W
r�
U
r.�
uJ:J _I
4
H I
0
—
HL=L
T�
ri
I
—
H W
r.
O
r.
r
/7♦
�y.